world articles part 3
U.S. Says It Has Unlocked iPhone Without Apple
Timothy D. Cook, Apple’s chief, defended the company’s battle with the government at an event last week.CreditAndrew Burton for The New York Times
By Katie Benner and Eric Lichtblau
SAN
FRANCISCO — The Justice Department said on Monday that it had found a
way to unlock an iPhone without help from Apple, allowing the agency to
withdraw its legal effort to compel the tech company to assist in a
mass-shooting investigation.
The
decision to drop the case — which involved demanding Apple’s help to
open an iPhone used by Syed Rizwan Farook, a gunman in the December shooting in San Bernardino, Calif., that killed 14 people — ends a legal standoff
between the government and the world’s most valuable public company.
The case had become increasingly contentious as Apple refused to help
the authorities, inciting a debate about whether privacy or security was
more important.
Yet law
enforcement’s ability to now unlock an iPhone through an alternative
method raises new uncertainties, including questions about the strength
of security in Apple devices. The development also creates potential for
new conflicts between the government and Apple about the method used to
open the device and whether that technique will be disclosed. Lawyers
for Apple have previously said the company would want to know the
procedure used to crack open the smartphone, yet the government might
classify the method.
“From a legal
standpoint, what happened in the San Bernardino case doesn’t mean the
fight is over,” said Esha Bhandari, a staff lawyer at the American Civil
Liberties Union. She notes that the government generally goes through a
process whereby it decides whether to disclose information about
certain vulnerabilities so that manufacturers can patch them.
Comments
Post a Comment